A review by: Penny Playbill
Cole Porter’s Kiss Me, Kate is no small undertaking. With its whip-quick shifts between backstage drama and Shakespearean farce ~ not to mention a score packed with Broadway standards ~ it demands a company that can deliver both style and stamina. I mean, come on, the opening of Act II is practically a marathon disguised as a dance number. And these dancers? They don’t disappoint.
Directed by Marybeth Berry, Town Theatre’s production has wit, polish, and a sense of fun, even when the show’s complexities peek through.
At the heart of the story are Jonathan Kupper and Shelby Sessler as Fred Graham and Lilli Vanessi. Kupper brings swagger and vocal heft to his Petruchio, while Sessler balances fiery defiance with vulnerable longing. Their constant push-and-pull keeps the relationship both maddening and irresistible. And Sessler’s “I Hate Men” deserves its own ovation ~ half the audience is laughing, the other half gasping, and everyone is thinking, did she really just say that?”
As Lois Lane, Karly Minacapelli Shorter radiates comic innocence, bubbling with energy. Many of Shorter’s facial expressions make you wonder, “is she really in there?” which happens to be the perfect embodiment of Lois. Stephen Fisher makes his Town Theatre debut as Bill Calhoun. He is charming and his engaging presence causes you to seek him out on the stage. We hope this is just the first of many appearances at 1012 Sumter Street.
Kayla Nagy Welch launches the night with powerhouse vocals in “Another Op’nin’, Another Show,” proving her Hattie is more than just an assistant. Rich Fisher as General Howell finds a solid stride in a new type of role (for him). He succeeds as we find ourselves rooting for the other guy, even though the other guy is kind of a jerk for most of the show. Will Dowd as Paul leads in the show’s dance highlight, “Too Darn Hot” – slightly different from his disco days as Lancelot in Town’s Spamalot. (We wish the written word could communicate the sarcasm in that last sentence!)
And let’s talk about “Too Darn Hot.” This number could buckle a weaker cast, but choreographer Joy Alexander says, “hold my beer” and doesn’t flinch. She takes a notoriously difficult piece and crafts it so the seasoned dancers shine while everyone onstage has a chance to contribute. The result? A true showstopper that just keeps going… and going. Every time you think the cast is about to collapse in exhaustion, they find one more gear.
Perhaps the funniest moments are shared by Jeff Sigley and Nathan Wright, as the gangsters. (Note: Kane Koestner is sharing the role with Sigley.) No matter who is playing, however, these guys land the evening’s broadest laughs with one-liners and their much-anticipated “Brush Up Your Shakespeare.” To deliver those lyrics with such deadpan expressions is a feat on its own. Speaking of lyrics, Katie Gatch’s music direction ensures Porter’s tricky text comes through crystal clear, no small task given the wordplay and tempo.
While the pacing of some of the older classic shows can lag and the shifts between the 1940s backstage world and the Shakespearean play can be abrupt, the cast is locked-in so the show doesn’t lose momentum for long. In fact, the set also gets a credit for being its own “character” helping to propel the show. Jeremy Hansard, Bob Bramhall and Mario Micallef have created a turntable that keeps things fluid between the two worlds. It provides an interesting visual instead of the typical blackout that is sometimes utilized. Paired with Jillian Bigony’s vibrant costumes (of two shows!), Jodie Harris’s wigs, and Gina Janvrin’s well-chosen props, the production has a polished, cohesive look that elevates the storytelling.
Town Theatre’s Kiss Me, Kate offers a vibrant, affectionate staging of a classic. It succeeds not just because of Porter’s wit and melody, but because of the collaborative effort of a company that throws itself fully into the joyous chaos of life on ~ and off ~ the stage. The show runs through September 28.
Penny Playbill has spent 42 years in local theatre. While not formally trained as a reviewer, she believes every show ~ and every cast ~ deserves a thoughtful spotlight.










